I had to pick up some clothes from the dry cleaners/menders on Camberwell Church Street today, but had to make a quick detour via Clerkenwell first as I’d left some meat in the fridge at work. As the wife’s out having lunch with a friend, I made it a leisurely voyage and allowed myself the luxury of stopping frequently to look around me.
What it reminded me is what a lovely place Camberwell can be; lots of Georgian & Edwardian terraced housing; long, straight leafy roads; little parks and squares dotted around it; plenty of sports facilities; nice pubs & bars.
What lets the whole area down is what most people see: Camberwell Green and its surroundings. Traffic-choked, dirty pavements, an abundance of off-licences and no shortage of clients for them. It doesn’t look nice, it doesn’t feel nice; it isn’t nice.
At the end of the voyage I dropped into the menders to pick up my clothes; two pairs of trousers, both of which had been fixed well, and at a very reasonable price. The name of the shop escapes me at the moment; it’s on the side of Cruson/Sophocles, further towards the Green. I’d like to know the story of the co-owner who, tragically, died on his 50th birthday, but I’m afraid to ask.
I noticed that work is still ongoing in the former Zara’s Kitchen; whatever’s going to open there, it involves a substantial refit. The former Rumeli has now definitively changed to Grills, etc. KFC is having a refit too; at first I thought they’d closed down, but no such luck. Still no sign of life in Angels & Gypsies.
Finally, a few nights ago I was in the Spar on Vestry Road, where a young man and his girlfriend were buying chocolate. Nothing seemed amiss, but the young man suddenly said “I want to shoot someone tonight, man; I feel like shooting someone up”. I wanted to slap his silly little baby-gangster face.
The Hermit’s Cave was buzzing on Saturday night.
They do need to crack down on girls smoking ciggies in the toilet though.
One older lady was quite dismayed by this abuse of the only cubicle.
The offender was really pretty though and wearing very short shorts so I have mixed feelings and can understand why she was reluctant to smoke outside.
To monopolise the only cubicle does seem a little heartless.
Anyone else see this girl with short white shorts?
That was like a Bob Dylan song.
There is a barmaid in the Funky Munky who is a bleached blonde from Mongolia. She is a student. Asked of what, the answer is, appropriately -
Beauty.
lol@benhill.
I’ll give you a second go: I used to work for pricewaterhousecoopers and so I now look forward to your disparaging comments about consultants, bring them on 😉
I’ve never distained community councils and groups, best of luck to them in trying. I used to work for southwark council many many years ago and know just how difficult it can be to make changes happen.
I admire Ian W for taking the time to come over and meet with us and for continuing to show willingness to help us. He’s the first councillor I met since that atrocious Vickie woman of some time ago, and he’s restored my faith in local politics.
To those who read this blog, if you need your local councillor’s help, email them. Thats what we did and we were very impressed by their responses. All 3 councillors from Brunswick ward contcted us individually.
All I’m saying is that I’m a realist. I like Camberwell just as it is. Sure, there are things I’d like to see fixed (hence why we contacted Ian in the first place) but they’re not bad enough to make me want to leave the place.
Yes I would probably also like any changes that community councils managed to get done but I don’t have the time to help them. I don’t believe I’m unique.
Wingfield & Co. are really on the ball, on the case, I agree. I like Camberwell just as it is — sg, great thing to say, not just realistic but recognising reality for what it is.
Trevor Philips today in the Indie:
“After a generation of neglect, some poorer communities, where many migrants settle, have to cope with under-resourced and unmodernised schools, housing and transport infrastructure. It would be arrogant to dismiss the feelings of people to whom the daily frictions of diversity are more apparent than its long-term benefits.”
Those that say they like Camberwell just as it is tend to live in a certain part of it; centre and south, else 9–5 ‘n’ drive. And to that extent, the argument holds steady — let’s just be clear where we’re talking about.
You can’t do everything, and at least Wingfield et al do something, with their limited powers. But only the Executive can effect true change.
But I can say with cast iron certainty that those who find the status quo across SE5 acceptable have never traded with the general public in North/North-West Camberwell, week in and week out.
This has actually been useful.
Reg, Mark and Co., stop. Just stop. There is nothing you can do. There is nothing you have accomplished. Just stop, all the talk, all the analysis, and disband the Forum. Admit it, after two years it hasn’t done anything. The one before it didn’t do anything and I’m understanding why now.
Why? Because, and I’m being serious not sarcastic, as I sort of knew, there is far more people of similar ilk that like Camberwell just like it is. Don’t change it. Sg and Dagmar and even Peter a I think fit that bill.
It really is helpful to hear you all admit that. I think my vision for what I want to see is at odds with the majority of people here. Knowing that makes it easier to ponder a move.
Love it or leave it makes perfect sense now.
Mark and Peter and this site and the Doves and the Forum have helped me to find my Camberwell. You may not have found yours Benhill but that doesn’t mean they have failed.
I am going to live here for ever- that is at least in part down to the people you are disparaging.
There are others though — including the good ladies at King’s who delivered our babies, the staff at their excellent nursery, the council workers who maintain all the brilliant parks we play in, the team that run the lido, and the staff of the many bars and restaurants we enjoy frequenting from ED to Bellenden to Church Street and beyond.
There is a busy crossroads and some tramps who get p:ssed. It’s a problem but there is more to Camberwell than that.
I’m sorry that you don’t like it. Good luck with your move.
You misrepresent my position, Benhill.
I don’t think all is fine and nothing needs to change; but neither do I think we’re living in some god-forsaken hell-hole that needs to be razed.
I think what we have here is a good solid base to build on, but we need to improve the facilities all around the area — not just the hub, but further out on the spokes as well.
Spokes? Recently I was pedalling home from work at night in the rain through the Aylesbury Estate, on Thurlow Road, in dreaded North Camberwell, north of north Camberwell, almost as awful, they say, as Walworth.
So swirly had the Elephant roundabout been, so drear was the night, I stopped at the Kurdish-ish shop near the English Martyrs Church. Anyone familiar with the Forty Martyrs of England and Wales will know the suffering and temptation I was enduring. Anyway, I fear I ramble.
I bought a can of Bison Beer — Zubr, European bison, the heaviest land animal in Europe — I fear I ramble — also called a “wisent”, related to the North American bison, often called buffalo, but which are only distantly related to water buffalo or African buffalo — so the buffalo of the great plains are really bison, the great sustainers of the plains Indians… Indian? Moravia, the bisons’ beer is from the Moravian region of Poland, perhaps the beer paradise garden of the world.
The half litre can had two bisons’ heads on it, I think, and was 6% abv or maybe 9, I wasn’t sure.
I am not taking the pee, it transformed my view of the Aylesbury — the bison’s piss — strong as an ox, full of bison’s hormones — EPO, testosterone, steroids, hops — the night black, the flashing blue lights, the yellow and orange light shining on the wet road. “Bring it on,“I said in the argot of the zeitgeist, “North Cambwerwell, I am ready for yew.”
Benhill — I find your position in part refreshing. Believe me, I am frustrated with the lack of progress.
We need to renew the Forum committee, as about have of them are deadweight passengers, good-willing or not. But whilst I respect your involvement in the Camberwell Forum, unless you have been involved in this one you should keep your criticism circumspect, and also remember that the part of Camberwell most express satisfaction with is not the part with the most serious problems.
There is another Castle.
There is another Camberwell.
Half.
Dagmar, in addition to florid and multi-meta-layered prose, I also think you make a very useful contribution to social debate. One of the most positive here.
“… spewing flowery adjectives…pedalling furiously…”
Moving off topic here. Food is more important.
@bunbohue will try Eastern Tree for sure.
Guess you’ve tried many of the Kingsland Rd places but Cay Tre on Old St was q special. Went there for my birthday. Even Giles Coren of the Times agrees in his review.
I realise that I’ve come in late in this ‘discussion’ and have never posted a comment before even though this I occasionally have a look at this site. This time however, i feel so saddened by some of your comments (good to know that good old fashioned bigotry and class snobbery is still alive and kicking in Camberwell — well South Camberwell at least! ) that I feel compelled to respond. As a young black women, I am probably in the minority here and no doubt I might be viewed as ‘scum’ by some of you who would rather the area be cleansed to make way for the well-heeled white folks who live over the hill. But let’s clarify a few points. I have lived in London for over 20 years, 10 of these have been spent in Camberwell. Before this I lived in lots of nice predominately, white middle-class areas: Notting Hill (a place many of you seem to view through rose-tinted spectacles), Battersea (the nice bit between the commons, not the shabby estates of the North), Pimlico and Crouch End. And guess what ? there’s crime there too ! In each area I lived there were high profile murders that occurred, and wealthly areas are often rich picking for burglars. I also have to add that in many of these nice areas, I was often told that jobs that I’d applied for in shops or restaurants had been filled, when this clearly wasn’t the case, I was often followed around shops by some concerned shopowner who would instantly assume that I’d come in to steal. I was told that flats for rent were taken when they weren’t and have had police stop and search my sister’s car when all we were doing was trying to move house in the evening. And no. This isn’t a sob story, I’m certainly not paranoid and I’m definitely not embracing victimhood. But I didn’t hate end up assuming that all whites were racist, or feel that I could never live in these areas again. I put it down to a few sad ignorant people I had the misfortune to meet. Sadly, it seems that many of you feel that you can’t do the same. Yes, there’s gun crime in Camberwell and it’s a problem but it’s carried out by a minority of young people (both black and white) who rather sadly choose the wrong role models to look up to. And anyway, what exactly is black on black crime ? The vast majority of drinkers in Camberwell are white — does this mean we have a white alcoholic problem in the area ? Most paedophile crimes (according to the media) seem to be committed by white males. Is this a predominately white problem ? Can this stereotyping get any more ridiculous ?
Unfortunately, we now live in a climate where the level of weaponry has increased from knives to guns (if guns had been so easily available back in the 60s than they are now, do you really think mods and rockers would have thought twice about using them ?) but demonising all young black boys does nothing to help the problem. How many young black men do you all know ? The ones I’ve met from both the Heygate and Aylesbury are just young people with the same dreams and aspirations as the rest of us — but just with less privilege. Most of the ‘poor african immigrants’ that you refer to are often ordinary people holding down two or three jobs to try to improve their lives — they’re not the sad, downtrodden, disenfranchised people that some of you seem to assume. And yes, Camberwell could do with more money, cleaner streets and better shops but it certainly ain’t a slum — has anyone ever been to a real slum ? Go to a slum in a developing country and you cerrtainly would think twice about labelling this area. Oh and by the way, I have friends who live in posh Islington who still face problems trying to find decent secondary schools for their kids. It’s seems that all the wealthy residents send their kids to private schools instead of trying the improve the ones that already exist. So these schools are left to deteriorate- this is often the problem with gentrification. The rich move in wanting to capitalise on affordable period property but are reluctant to mix with the people who already live there, the result is two parallel cultures — Peckham rye (or posh peckham) is a prime example. African and West Indian culture is never going to be as quiet and reserved as white middle-class culture and there’s no reason why it should be — but it doesn’t have to be frightening. A lot of you just seem to want to turn Camberwell into another Clapham/Notting Hill/East Dulwich full of yummy mummys and nice, quiet, professional middle-class people as if this is a lifestyle that we should all be aspiring to. I happen to work in an environment which is predominately full of Oxbridge grads and have to put up with ignorant and thinly veiled racist comments about how terrible areas of Camberwell, Peckham and Brixton are — when I challenge them I find out that most have never even visited. But to get this from people who actually live here ??? And Benhill — where are your friends who won’t visit from ? Surrey ? Hampshire ?
If you want to improve things there’s plenty you could do instead of waiting for the council to sort things out. There are many great mentoring schemes that are desperate for older, intelligent people to join and make a difference to some of these kid’s lives. A lot of black kids in the area don’t know or mix with any white people and I know for a fact that these schemes are keen for more white men to sign up. This is how barriers get broken down. If anyone is interested and wants more details, please let me know. I know someone who is currently training to do this and he finds it really interesting.
And Mark, to be honest I think the real reason that some people are reluctant to visit your pub is not due to its location, it’s down to the staff. I have heard this from a number of people (some of whom live in Camberwell, others used to live in the area). I don’t know whether the staff feel that it’s cool to be rude and stand-offish but I’ve often felt offended by how I’ve been served on a number of occasions when I’ve visited. I’ve even witnessed a very calm, level-headed friend have a heated argument with one of the bar staff, because he was so rude. They just don’t seem to care. The last time I was in there I was served a flat spritzer on two occasions. When I complained I was told there was nothing wrong with it. Thankfully the bar manager who there that night was more sympathetic and agreed to give me a fresh drink. Anyway, still love the film nights…
My point is don’t give up on Camberwell, it’s got plenty of potential, but if you don’t want to live with us ethnics well… maybe you need to downsize to Dulwich.
Wow… what a way to make your first post! Welcome, bavent; I hope you stick around as a reader and keep commenting.
I agree witht he majority of your comments Bavent but I can’t believe the spritzers are flat in the Sun and Doves.
Mark do you need to get a new cannister for your soda stream?
bavent — I read that in awe!. Great post
bevant, What a superb post.
Wow! Did you write that after watching the film?
Bavent, thank you for so much common sense.
Bevant — I enjoyed your post; a breath of fresh air. I agree with a lot of what you say.
Here are my thoughts on the very few points where I was not certain of agreement. Although others will also disagree some of your points, you will tend to find a void of silence here in between the veiled racism which you referred to (a small minority) and fulsome and unmitigated praise (the majority) of your remarks, on the subjects of cultural and racial prejudice. It tends to be rainbow nation or rivers of blood.
I do think improving NEW (North East & West) Camberwell necessitates articulating the things that are wrong with it, and that this need not necessarily be a criticism of any specific ethnic community.
I think the various African cultures alone, let alone Caribbean, contain such massive variations that it is not proper to speak of “white” and “black” culture in Camberwell. Indeed, more significant tensions and disconnects arguably exist between elements of African and Caribbean communities, than white and African. It is precisely this cultural variation that gives the lie to “black on black” being “nothing to do with the white community”. Also, the failure to mix tends to be based on wealth. Poor mix with poor, whilst the rich drive everywhere and build walls.
I also believe that any ethnic minority community should retain its identity, habits etc. but should respect the law, including those laws against pavement parking, litter and noise pollution. There should be no positive discrimination through non-enforcement in recognition of “cultural values”. This is not to say that I believe white people commit less of these crimes.
However, because of the higher concentration of ethnic minority communities in NEW Camberwell, the relevant local authorities commit less money to enforce basic laws. And I believe this to be indirect racial discrimination under the Race Relations (Amendment) Act 2000, under which all local authorities have a duty to promote racial equality, let alone not indirectly discriminate. No such case, incidentally, has yet been brought against a public authority, which reflects the lack of seriousness with which the general issue is taken. The anti-social behaviour which thereby results impacts more heavily on the very ethnic minority communities who become characterised by it, although few of them engage in it.
I like your suggestion of mentoring. Such schemes are a definite part of the solution, as you describe, and we should not wait for the local authorities to act. But we should give them every encouragement and incentive to do so that we can possibly imagine.
In short, I echo Peter’s and others’ welcomes. It may interest you to know that several of the SE5 Forum committee will shortly be standing down in time for the AGM, and would probably be very interested to have you as a representative, as I certainly would.
bavent, I mean.
Spot on Reg. Though I\‘m not sure we should punish the \‘rich\’ for \‘building walls and driving cars\’ so much. I think those pockets have grown out of frustration and it will take a lot to talk them down. A closed road up in the Grove is a first step toward another wall going up. I suspect they\‘ll fight to keep it. I don\‘t agree with it, but I don\‘t blame them. Many worked very hard to restore a beautiful landmark and keep up some huge gardens, only to have a constant stream of booming cars tossing rubbish out. You are bordering on punishing those who have worked hard and have invested heavily in maintaining a beautiful community. At some point, I want my hard graf to enhance the community, not just suffer for those who have no respect, no pride and just trash the place.
Bevant, I agree with most of what you say too. I\‘m on record for many years as saying the Afro Caribbean community here is one of our biggest opportunities to create a unique community. My \‘rainbow\’ street is spectacular. I know most all of them, they come from all over and they are good people, good neighbours. And yes, many have black teens and I have gotten to know them. A few years back, one came to work with me in the City for a few weeks in the summer and I worked with him on getting into his preferred University. He\‘s now in a trainee programme with a bank. Further, I fund and support when I can the Camberwell Choir at St Giles. It is an outstanding way to bring the next generation together and music is a wonderful tool. They will grow up not caring about silly things like skin colour.
For all those who shouted \‘hear hear\’ to your post, I\‘m keen to hear them answer your valid questions. How many young black men (people) do you know? Do you mentor either formally or informally? What are you actively doing in Camberwell to break down barriers?
I\‘ve long fought against us becoming another Clapham or such. And again, I think our diversity is what could make us very different. But increasingly, there is just plain rudeness and threatening behaviour that makes the daily live grim. I\‘m not even talking about serious crime, though it is on the agenda across the UK. As stated clearly, I think we have challenges of a large immigrant population. Here, they just happen to be from African/Caribbean origins. And we have challenges unique to those communities. To say I, or anyone else here, means we don\‘t want that kind around here is way off the mark. I\‘m just saying let\‘s put it on the table and deal with it, in a way that is inclusive and not territorial. We must all take responsibility and not play victim.
Now I\‘ll ask you a few question Bevant, if I may. Groups past and present have always struggled to engage minority (arguably not minority in Camberwell) groups. We end up with Forums, Societies and the like full of white, mostly middle class. And we have tried. New Forum people, am I right for you all? Groups have struggled to engage the whole of Camberwell and proactively push things forward. What can we do?
hi, and good to hear positive and probing feedback — reg and benhill — you make valid points and i agree, the problems are much more complex than sweeping generalisations, but I didn’t want to write a book just a shortish message ! But I’d also like to make it clear that these are my opinions and my mine alone. I don’t profess to speak for every black person who lives in Camberwell. I’m sure others will think differently. I know that it’s a problem getting people involved — from my limited experience, people will get involved with things that directly affect them i.e. housing etc and lobby the council for things that might affect their road or estate or whatever, but nothing more. I;ve had a look on the SE5 forum website and thought about coming to a meeting — but to be honest, I’ve often wondered exactly what you do, whether you have any political or persuasive power, or whether it’s more of a social forum — perhaps this is the problem. It doesn’t feel compulsory. I’d really like to respond in more detail to this but it’s late and sleep is calling, I’ll try again over the weekend.
Grills etc. in Camberwell are definitely new and fresh. Not much of the old Rumeli is there apart from the old grill equipment. Having said that tried I the Moroccan chicken kebab with rice once and the Mongolian barbecue also (from lamb chops).…..and it’s a nice alternative to the old traditional Turkish kebabs
i googled grills etc se5 and stumbled upon this interesting thread. and it makes me laugh that the comment above me is also regarding grills etc!
all my friends love camberwell when they visit. When they tell others where i live they often make comments about south london involving the word ‘dodgy’ which i find hilarious as mostly they’re non london / a bit racist idiots who heard something on the news. it makes me sad when it’s londoners saying these things about camberwell though. i really find it has quite a casual charm and i won’t be moving anywhere else soon. it’s sad that people can’t see beyond camberwell green. obviously there are problems or this thread wouldn’t exist and i’m not one to glaze over everything with an argument of ‘niceness’ but i really do love camberwell. everyone i know at university lives in camden/tufnell park/euston and other NW areas which is horrible to me.
i think another reason people like to slag camberwell off is that it hasn’t got a tube station — they don’t realise how well connected it is. honestly, my housemate goes to goldsmiths and his friends won’t bother to visit. and we all know new cross is much crapper than camberwell.
also WE HAVE A NANDO’S. which now has halloumi on the menu.
does anyone have a number for Ben at Bar Story
Bar Story is 0207–635 6643.
Bavent (post no. 114 above), where are you? Lucas Gardens was great today, burgeoning. The SLG show has made it to the top 5 art shows in London in today’s Independent.