First bit of bad news: Network Rail are planning to drop the London Bridge to Victoria route, meaning Denmark Hill’s usefulness will be reduced by about a third. As a ‘consolation’, services that we can get to by changing trains will be increased; not actually that useful when the trains to get to those services are reduced by half.
I had a pretty strong feeling this would happen, as soon as they began the ‘public consultation’ — a sop to regulators when a decision has already been made. Network Rail accepts that the proposals contain “significant passenger disbenefits”, but doesn’t care.
Second bit of bad news: A report on the radio says that a woman has been stabbed to death in County Grove. Can’t find any details, or indeed any confirmation, of that yet, so know idea what’s involved. It’s far too early to draw any conclusions yet, or to make any connections with any other crimes in the area, but at the very least it’s an unneccessary loss of life, and more ammunition for those who’d like to paint the area as a crime-ridden slum.
Update: Some more detail about this incident; seems to have been a domestic rather than street crime. Exactly why I was cautious about jumping to conclusions.
Anyway, do enjoy the rest of your day.
“Shit the bed” – consequences of dinner in Safa? Or the Viet place? A long session in the Silver Buckle?
I’ll get my coat.
To make up for my last unsavory post, we had a great weekend in Camberwell.
School’s back. Normal stuff is happening all around. Like it.
One thing about the Internet though, you can’t really talk about all the great stuff there is for kids, in case some freak figures you out. I suppose it’s safe enough to mention we went to the South London Gallery – you are allowed to climb all over the place, literally.
It was the last day of that exhibit, but I overheard that the new show (upcoming) will keep the vibe going, with platforms and ladders installed among the art exhibits.
Woa, that Guardian article is depressing.
Our eldest is coming up to secondary school age. Where can you send kids to get an education that will give them the academic capability to compete in this global, knowledge economy? Should we move?
Good find, Mumu. There has been filming at King’s A&E, too. There will be a documentary on the telly about knife crime, with the staff at King’s explaining what really happens to people when they’re knifed.
The SLG show I thought was OK — I too went on the last day, Sunday, and chortled about the name of the chap who made the video, Gustavo Artigas. Artigas! There’s a lot of that round here, it’s called critical theory.
Still, Lottie Child I thought was the star of the show. She is extremely interesting, disciplined, skilled, humorous and inspirational about creative play in the streets. She will conduct two of her street training sessions starting from Peckham Square on 20 September at 2pm and 4pm. Be there or be square. If you are square, she will round you, don’t worry about that!
Hello, sorry to break the discussion. Would anyone know a reliable local plumber that they would recommend?
@ Alan: Nope. Via de la Plata.
@ A lurker: This guy was recommended on the SE5 forum.
YEs I can indeed, I second that recommendation for Maurice Yeoman 07837163978
He came to my flat to give me a quote this morning, friendly polite, punctual and reasonably priced (though I don’t think he’s CORGI registered)
I had an awful time on the bog this morning. My guts spilt into the pan. But I grabbed my toothbrush and shoved ’em back up.
@49 Mumu — thanks for the link.
If the govt was REALLY serious about knife crime, then perhaps tackling it in Peckham, Brixton and Camberwell would be a good place to start.
Perhaps putting up airport style scanners at the gates of every school in the area and also setting them up randomly in high street areas and marching anyone under 20 through them.
I suspect most adults living in the area would support this for a limited period of time, to weed out the knife carriers?
Do you think? But then again, it costs money and doesn’t translate into votes, I suppose.
The Via de la Plata looks sublime, Peter, the shining path, the silver blade of beauty and peace, trade and intercourse.
Went along to the Camberwell Baths/Leisure Centre meeting this evening. Besides a few problems with a malfunctioning microphone I thought it was pretty interesting. As each bid was only a design proposal they were all relatively vague about costs and other specific detail.
Here are my thoughts on the 3 proposals and presentations:
1) Fusion — pretty lacklustre presentation with very little detail. Seemed to be keeping the main pool building and then just developing 64 residential units out the back. I may be wrong but their design photo seemed to show them pedestrianising Artichoke Place (road leading to the main entrance). Their main point was that that their team had done the work on the refurbished Brockwell Lido and that was very successful.
2) Ash Sakula — plan to retain pool and leisure facilities, put in Russian/Turkish baths in the basement and create 26 residential units, some of which would be 4⁄5 bed houses. A much more professional presentation and from what I could gather they will be keeping as much of the original structure as possible. Theirs seemed like a more innovative design compared to Fusions but they didn’t really mention who would be running the pool/leisure centre. Just checked out their website and they have been involved in some interesting projects: http://www.ashsak.com
3) English National Ballet — a bit more of a radical plan in that they want to do away with the pool (turning it into studio space) but keep some leisure facilities. Only plan to have 15 residential units so less extra building. They want Camberwell to be the home of the ENB and they want to engage the community through dance, music and movement. I’d say they were probably the reason why most people went along and they got a bit of a hostile reception, however I thought the MD gave a very impressive talk about what they could bring to Camberwell.
The question was asked whether or not the pool could be kept and ENB still come and make use of the other space as their dance studio. Unfortunately unless the council stump up the cash to refurbish the pool, ENB don’t have the money to do that.
If it was up to me, I’d go for the ENB option as it would definitely help to put Camberwell on the map and it also fits in nicely with Camberwell being seen as a place for the arts. Yes, the pool does go, but I think sometimes you have to make sacrifices if you want progress. Maybe the schools who currently use the pool can use those facilities at Peckham Pulse and Dulwich Leisure Centre which aren’t too far away. Or alternatively they kids can take dance classes instead of going swimming.
Unfortunately I’d say Fusion will probably get it as theirs was apparently the highest ranked submission (don’t ask me how) and they already run a few SE London leisure centres and have probably built up some decent connections in the Council. With Southwark Council ditching Camberwell as it head office shortly, we need something else to spark this area into life and what better than being the home of a national ballet company?
If anyone else went along, I’d be interested to hear your thoughts?
@41 Mark,
Saw you at the Camberwell Baths meeting last night — there’s no way you’re fifty!!!
why do I not have permission to edit my own comment, I only wanted to add an RSVP to the party invite. I can’t come I’m afraid, I’m at the Proms in the Park that evening, which is a shame because I would have definitely liked to attend!
Fusion are dire in my experience. Management and administration at Peckham Pulse is appalling. And they seem to have sanitised out of Brockwell lido all that was good and ropey (the West Indian man on the tannoy, the Judge Dredd lifeguards). I think Fusion is like Greenwich Leisure: a Trust set up by the Local Boroughs to handle leisure facilties floated off by the LBs. They retain the usual LB levels of service, though (anyone remember “The Pool” skit from The Day Today?) Would be a great shame to lose another pool. Don’t ENB do synchronised swimming?
Who else went? PK’s excellent summary suggests that one of the pack-’em-in residential schemes will get it. The ballet sounds great, though, would bring a bit of aspiration and excellence to Camberwell rather than dumbing.
I didn’t manage to get along to teh meeting — work intervening as always.
I woiuld be keen on the Ash Sakula proposals as i know their work and they produce some very nice stuff. Also teh Turkish Bath model has worked very well in Ironmonger Row Baths, Islington and also in Tower Hamlets. However key to me supporting it would be the appointemnt of a decent organisation to run the baths and ensuring they are at a price locals can afford.
PK -
I was there last night, I agree it was an interesting evening. I came away from it ultimately disappointed that there was no one-size-fits-all solution, although not at all surprised, it was naive of me to hope for one.
I also agree about the ENB, I was really impressed with them, their enthusiasm and drive and I agree that having their national and ceremonial home here would be a great thing. I good better vibes off the ENB people rather than the architect they were working with.
However they were very honest and stated up front that they would be getting rid of the swimming pool, and that is a subject a lot of people feel very stongly about so I fear we will have to wave goodbye to them.
Nice write-up, PK.
The place is such a dump at the moment, anything would be better (apart from Fusion, natch). There’s a horrendous stench in the place and lack of basic cleanliness.
I’d give it to some fluffy squatters to run as community centre. Tofu breakfasts, juggling classes, Linux workshops, etc
Can’t believe they trying to close Spike in Peckham. http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2008/aug/27/housing.communities
The council has truly lost it. Hopefully the Town Hall can be turned into something worthwhile when they’re gone. Maybe the credit crunch will make it less appealing to turn into shit-box apartments.
Was there last night as well and although an interesting evening I was disappointed at how poorly the councillor in charge of the decision-making process (Lewis Robinson?) explained the history and the next steps. “Going through the motions” has never seemed a more apt process
My initial views?
Fusion/PTE — limp presentation; safe option for the council as existing arrangement whilst the design can always be changed in the next phase; personally I’m be very concerned about the current poor Fusion management and would like to see them held to any current SLAs before they promise new ones…
Ash Sakula — good-looking designs and reasonable presentation; almost too honest in stating where the new flats would be as people reacted badly to that; loved their approach of cultivating a community trust to run the revamped centre and would like the council to pick that up whoever is selected
ENB — great passion and enthusiasm and good to see such an organisation showing an interest in the area; think it’s too large a step change for the centre of Camberwell
We’re reasonably new residents to the area, so not quite up to speed with what’s happening, did I hear right that the council will be making a decision in October on whether the swimming pool needs to be kept?
D‑MAN @ 53
“Our eldest is coming up to secondary school age. Where can you send kids to get an education that will give them the academic capability to compete in this global, knowledge economy? Should we move?”
No, need to move you can send them to Mary Datchelor or Wilson’s School for Boys — Whoops, they were abolished by the government forced to close and re-located in Surrey as private schools.
Still, I’m sure all those M.P’s who voted to abolish them are very proud of the subsequent legacy that they have left behind for the citizens of Camberwell and Southwark…Nothing like closing off avenues to a BETTER education to ALL kids who happen to live in one of the poorest boroughs in London
They knew a thing or two about a thing or two — and no mistake
Let’s thank them for their stirling efforts in knowing what is best for us all
I know I certainly appreciated it — getting taught by woefully inadequate supply teachers for 6 years in the brave new world of all-inclusive state education
Marvelous!
Nice houses though!
Please clarify Camberwell Baths is the boxing club in Burgess Park, NOT the leisure centre next to the Funky Munky.
Agreed?
Nice houses, for sure.
The lack of secondary schools is holding back property prices in a big way – there’s no incentive for the middle income guardian readers with kids to come here. The higher income segment that lives locally tend to use private schools.
Eusebio, your spelling is certainly execrable and your punctuation punktiddlious! However, you make up for it in enthusiasm, humour and invaluable, informed opinion through many years of experience in Camberwell and for this reason I give you 4 out of 10.
Another Baths meeting report here on SE5 Forum.
ENB is definitely the one to put Camberwell on the transport planners’ maps, the only obstacle (for those who see the loss of bathing facilities as unacceptable) being the Council funding the initial renovation/installation of the pool and changing facilities.
There will need to be more concentration on Camberwell’s fair share of the Southwark capital fund, based on SE5’s deprivation and residential density, if such obstacles are to be overcome. Southwark has a > £1 billion annual turnover, so why not examine that more closely, rather than accept it as all being “operational”?
Then there’s the Great Leader’s recent initiative to promote “free swimming for all”, surely of some application in this high-density Labour enclave, and with 80% of Council funding coming from general taxation?
Conscientious Camberwellians with leisure time are spoilt for choice tonight — SE5 Forum committee meeting or the seminar on the tram.
Dagmar @73
Many Thanks…
Not quite sure what happened there, my punctuation was all over the place this morning.
4 out of 10? You’re a hard woman to please… 😉
Ah, but it’s worth the strenuous effort and they sleep like babies after! Actually, I am seasonally melancholy which makes me dreamy and silly — I pass the Michaelmas daisies in the suburban gardens between Camberwell and West Norwood every day — they have clocks like dandelion clocks. So not only are the Michaelmas daisies saying goodbye to the summer, but as the flowers die, they leave a clock behind which ticks loudly here in the waiting room… “Tick-tock, tick-tock, the last flowers are gone, leaving this clock.” Oh, the tears are flowing again.
Tram thing was this morning so no conflict with Camberwell Forum. Anyone go?
Love ENB but hate to lose the pool. Housing trade-off makes sense. We can’t demand more than we are willing to give. Camberwells contribution to the Council pot is low so we have to find ways to generate money. If they decided to give the lowest contributing wards a new school, tube and Leisure Centre it would be unfair. And if they did, we’d price out most locals and become Clapham.
Newroad, most Council expenditure is from central Government, and much of that not from income tax, but corporation tax, customs duties, chain smoking and alcohol duties (disproportionately the poor) and VAT. So this “low-contributing wards” theory is completely irrelevant to how the Borough invests its money, morally or whatever. As I’ve said before, if Camberwell’s local economy was freed up by fair planning reforms, it could give a lot more than certain Dulwich wards contribute to the 20% local government pot you are talking about, and even become a BID. Small businesses all over SE5 are crying out to expand whilst money-grubbing landlords keep empty commercial properties locked up, hoping to convert to the sh1t-boxes to which D‑Man refers.
Also, SE5 housing is already completely unaffordable to most locals if they are not long on the ‘ladder or on a welfare promise. So stop being a London altruist and start talking up Camberwell, please.
I’m also keen to hear whether anyone made that — daytime as I should have known — tram meeting, and whether there was debate between the agencies or more of a presentation of their positions to each other.
Newroad: “If they decided to give the lowest contributing wards a new school, tube and Leisure Centre it would be unfair.”
You have a rather stark view of the role of government — in my book it is precisely these areas that need the government investment to promote regeneration, prosperity and employment.
I personally think that Camberwell’s problem is that it is squeezed in the middle between rich and poor. As a result it does not attract the regeneration investment that Elephant, Walworth, Peckham, Brixton etc get because it is not poor enough but does not have the wealth of Dulwich for example which attracts businesses.
The ENB proposals from what Ive read of them do seem to be attractive but it would be wrong to lose the community facility of the swimming pool without the promise of a new one.
My instinct says go for the ballet. My instinct is as strong as my thighs.
According to the BBC the tram link future is ‘pessimistic’ — http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/london/7607408.stm
My instinct says ballet too. A ludicrous sport, but a classy one!
@62 Thanks for that genfink. I feel older yet younger all at the same time.
Baths. It is time that Camberwell faced up to some realities. We can have the lesisure facilities we deserve but only if we make them happen. This means some form of Community Trust and some hard nosed work shoving and pushing local authorities and pulling lots of people together behind a do-able vision. The process we’re involved with that was the meeting last night is a direct outcome of last year’s Camberwell Baths working group not getting their act together (I include myself in this criticism) and leaving Southwark with no option other than to throw it our for creative tender.
We could have done it all in house — i.e. in Camberwell — but NO. No that would be too straightforward and mean too many people thinking outside of their comfortable shabby run down Camberwell box.
Of the proposals presented it is a shame that Fusion’s assembled coalition was so apologetic and down key. I feel that Fusion could do a good job but somehow are damned with this site.
Ash Sakula were upbeat and interesting and enthusiastic with their Russian bath in the basement idea. There was a lot of resistance to their building so many new housing in such a tight site — I think we’re in a tight area of dense population anyway so SO WHAT if some better conceived, better designed and built extra new accommodation were tucked in to the centre? Would be a good thing and could offer the opportunity to open the back area towards the Courts up to more people and activity.
BUT I’m rooting for English National Ballet. They MEAN what they say about integration and engagement. Their roots are about community and dissemanation of dance to as broad an audience as possible — iN spite of the lecture Michelle gave me to the contrary at the end of the meeting because I showed support for ENB setting up shop here… I mean they’ve even got an Aussie as MD.
Camberwell needs a major shot in the arm to resucitate it. The other schemes will not do this. More people will be brought in to dance than will ever swim in those baths — just because the baths are horrid and making them unhorrid and up to contemporary standars is way out of budget for any scheme under 15 million. And we’re not getting 15 million schemes presented.
So I suggest we get used to the idea that there is no way the baths can live on where they stand, short of a financial miracle happening — like Camberwell winning the Euro Lottery this Friday or us all getting together and agreeing to set up a Development Trust to make it happen (not in a month of full blue moon Sundays could that happen here) — and embrace ENB’s arrival big time and work with ENB to rebuild Camberwell’s status from scratch pulling in all the other international important centres of excellence we have on our doorstep — Maudsley, Kings, IOP, Camberwell College, South London Gallery and the others I can’t recall just now, find some land, build a new leisure facility that meets the community’s needs and costs about half what the Leisure Centre needs spending on it and go for a new high school in the area at the same time.
Aplopogies for the ytops
And by the way this is doable, I’m not THAT kind of dreamer.
Well said Mark. Completely agree that the ENB proposal is the one that will really make a difference to Camberwell. I just hope there are enough people who realise this and support them. I know it probably won’t make a difference, but I’ve emailed the councillors who were at the meeting to pledge my support for the ENB and it would be great if others did the same.
If ENB was to work, one model might be what the Laban have done in Deptford. I think the community “offer” end of the ENB’s proposal would need to be examined very closely, ideally by people who have epxerience in this area. And extra money levered in where necessary (from the Lottery, Hamlyn, ACE etc). It wouldn’t be enough just for ENB to honour us with their pale well toned presence.
One downside of the ballet – how many Range Rovers can fit into Artichoke Place at the same time?
On the upside – ballet is a little like gymnastics and Camberwell has a very good and engaged community gymnastics club
Hear, hear Mark.
One of the bus garages should become a pool/leisure complex. I mentioned this in jest on th Forum site but have since convinced myself it would be bloody marvellous! A win, win, win, win, win! I say if TfL don’t provide us with some form of quick and reliable transport soon we storm and lay claim to the garage we like best.
Did you know that one of the biggest hurdles those behind the Globe Theatre had to overcome was that the council didn’t want to relocate a facility for storing bin men’s stuff?
I doubt very much whether having the ENB will bring any benefits to Camberwell. LAMDA — the world famous drama school — is in Baron’s Court. It has zero effect on Baron’s Court. No one says, “O Baron’s Court — home of LAMDA.” The London Symphony Orchestra is near Waterloo. Its presence has zero effect on the area. Camberwell already has three great institutions — King’s, the Institute of Psychiatry and the Art College. Yet its legion problems haven’t been cured. How is the ENB going to put Camberwell on the map if the Art College hasn’t? If Camberwell loses its leisure centre, it will never get another one. No bus garage will ever be converted; no empty space waiting for a leisure centre will be discovered. The Leisure Centre will simply be added to the list of things that Camberwell doesn’t have: no decent shops, no tube stop, no sports facilities. Camberwell will get ever closer being a cross-roads in the middle of nowhere — where North Dulwich meets West Peckham meets East Brixton and South Elephant.
And the idea of the people of Camberwell putting aside their swimmers and pulling on ballet pumps is just silly.
We’re all doomed!
Hey everybody it’s my birthday today, if you’re in Mayfair pop by for a piece of cake!
It’s clear to me that Southwark Council has absolutely no intention of keeping Camberwell Baths open considering their vast expendure on Peckham Pomp and East Dulwich pools recently.
Rather than let one of the finest Architectural Gems in Camberwell go to waste, thus giving the useless local authority carte blanche to demolish it — I would rather the English National Ballet took over the building and got a grant and donations to restore and refurbish it
I know some believe it might not have a huge effect on Camberwell but as far as I’m concerned the more artistic,cultural and educational bodies that locate in Camberwell the better — We can use all the support of these institutions to heavily lobby the Council in community meetings and forums.
The council will always ignore the concerns of us humble proles but if we had the weight of these organizations behind and working with us — eventually they would be forced to change their policy
And that can only be a good thing…
Camberwell College of Arts
English National Ballet (potentially)
Kings College Hospital
Salvation Army
That’s an enviable quartet of influence that just hasn’t been tapped up — most communities would love to call upon such riches…
Agree with a lot of what you say Julian, but not the comparison with LAMDA and the LSO, mainly because the ENB studios would be in the thick of it. Very much a feature of Camberwell’s epicentre.
I hope one day we have a gang called the Tutu Boyz. Rock hard.
So it is this Camberwell Baths
http://www.flickr.com/photos/johnnystewart/14184676/
not this Camberwell Baths
http://www.flickr.com/photos/37541982@N00/1233480798/
I definitely vote for adding ballerinas to the local nightlife even though I think anyone claiming that a load of half starved posh girls will help the local working classes is mental..
Thanks for Clarifying. D‑MAN.
Is the Burgess Park baths at risk at all?!
Is that one called something else then?
Both buildings are architectural gems from the period of socialist empowerment — after all the needless destruction perpetuated by the crass dullards of the local authority — places such as these should be automatically Grade 1 listed
No arguments…
From a period of stinking BO and weekly communal bathing.
If the Burgees Park one was Grade 1 they wouldn’t have been allowed to land the butterfly on the side..
Socialists empowerment?! I think you are confusing them with the Aylesbury Estate.
Florian’s right, Julian, about Laban and Alan about ballerinas in Camberwell, Baron’s Court being barren.
Maybe it would just be easier for us all to accept that a turd can’t be polished…
Nice one euse, I’d forgotten that one. I’ve been buffing like hell around here for over ten years and it’s still a…
The thing, Julian, about the other institutions in the area is that they have been here all through Camberwell’s rise and fall and inevitably are part of the problem in that they have all suffered long — just as residents and businesses have done — over years of local authority neglect toward Camberwell. They have all had to look inward to keep stable and have not been significantly impacting on the community. They have all known this now for some time and have the will to work together to try to end the blight. A new big cultural player on the scene in Camberwell will be a shot of adrenaline in the mix and could be pivotal to the town’s renaissance if used well by Camberwell to promote Camberwell.
The Leisure Centre is a dead cause as a swimming baths. In spite of what everyone says about its elegance, beauty, pleasure of experience can you imagine anyone growing up having swum there regularly seriously wanting to take up swimming long term or ever looking back with rose tinted glasses on and saying ‘what a joy it was going to Camberwell baths’. No.
To make Camberwell baths properly fit for 21 Century purpose it needs to be completely gutted and rebuilt internally from the basement up and beyond. Few people are prepared to admit this but it is a fact. This is a vastly more expensive exercise than ANY formal proposal that has been put forward so far and there is no economic evidence to suggest it would be financially viable in the long, or even short, term. There are only so many ways to cut a cake and, although in our dreams there are ways of making the site work, reality dictates it will never get the investment it needs to make a swimming pool work in that space.
Therefore a process of deduction suggests that ENB’s proposal is more sustainable long term than the others — it is less of a financial burden than the other schemes and from the outset has a copper bottomed income stream to keep it thriving, growing and investing in the area long term. I accept entirely the point that ENB’s commitment to community engagement and outreach be closely looked at as well as their stated desire to work with Brunswick Gym club and other local groups desperately needing space whose activities could be a good fit with ENB’s. Encouraging ENB to take a role in Camberwell Arts Festival and add a whole raft of activities that have been under resourced locally and having the site as an active public venue would have an amazing impact on the area.
AT the same time as supporting ENB I personally will be banging on about there being an absolute need for high quality local swimming provision i.e. NOT Peckham but Camberwell and encouraging people to come together to make a new build happen in Camberwell. It will be much cheaper than saving or preserving the existing baths in the half cocked under capitalised way the site can afford.