On Saturday we had the privilege of seeing Camberwell (and the rest of London) from above, as we took advantage of the Open House day at the William Booth Memorial College to climb the pigeon-shit-encrusted spiral stairs of the tower and take a look at the fantastic vista it overlooks. I have some nice pictures, which I’ll post shortly. At the top of the tower I met Merrick, of this blog’s comments fame. Not sure if anyone else was around at the time I was; I was there at about 3pm. I was the one with the scruffy beard and the sun-kissed look.
On the way down to the Chinese supermarket to get some fish, I noticed that Willow has closed down. Restaurants just don’t seem able to hold their own in this area.
I didn’t attend the march to save Camberwell Baths; call me cynical, but I think marches have to be backed up with something a little more substantial. We live in a society where facilities are judged not by their usefulness, but by their ability to turn a profit; in order to show that the Baths are of use to the community, they need to be used more — however, in order to be used more, they need to be cleaned up and reformed. Catch 22. Instead of a march, there should have been a swim-in; everyone pays their money and fills the pool. The sight of all that money crossing the counters would have the owners far more interested.
Finally, here’s possibly my favourite bit of Camberwell history I’ve ever read:
Army and Navy pensioners held a cricket match between one-armed and one-legged veterans in Camberwell, London, in August 1841. The Army lost by 19 runs to 176, allegedly because they had more one-legged players.
Pulse is rejuvenated since pool opened. Swimming lessons for children there are excellent. But front of house staff are rather poor. And soft play smells of feet. CGS money very over-subscribed this year. Seems to me that Camberwell east of Denmark Hill and south of Church St is basically fine; other areas less so. Probably more to do with area demographic than any council malfeasance.
Mark you’re right. But with a lot of respect mate, what is missing to unite the voices of SE5 is leadership. I think you are fantastic and have a lot to offer, god knows you’ve given loads, but we need a leader. We haven’t had one. All the negatives you point out are what a leader would overcome. You have invested more time and money in Camberwell than anybody I know. I stand in awe of you. But we haven’t had the right leadership for the Forum or anything else to make tracks. And sorry reg, parking isn’t the root of all evil.
Florian — “Probably more to do with area demographic…” — Not too sure what you mean.
It’s true that the Council’s BME business policy is harmful, in that it creates a culture of entitlement in parts of ethnic minority communities which blunts their entrepreneurism. It purports to correct an imbalance where none exists, and in doing so creates an imbalance. Who knows, in the future such a policy might even result in an oversupply of certain types of business associated with certain ethnic minorities.
But the real problem with the Council is non-feasance. Inaction on planning enforcement, indifference to crime levels and to pavement parking offences against the community, and to the shop block of residents. The demographic is only relevant insofar as the Council makes judgments about prioritising investment based on that demographic. Unless you are saying something else…
Anyone who works for the Council would naturally be perturbed by a suggestion that basic services are being bled away from Camberwell to mickey mouse initiatives in neighbouring regeneration areas Peckham Dulwich and Elephant. It is indeed a shameful truth.
by demographic I meant that the middle classes tend to demand more of the council and be more active citizens, so eg on planning issues. this in turn tends to reflect in the prioritisation councils give to the areas where they live and on the consequent quality of environment. in se5, this is particularly noticeable. se15 too. non or mis not mal feasance as you say. trick for southwark and others is to help regenerate civil society in those areas that need it most. not easy.
Florian — I don’t agree with your assessment of the demographic. “Wilderness areas” such as Wyndham Road, Camberwell New Road, Coldharbour Lane, and Camberwell Road are fringed with districts containing judges, barristers, bank directors, and media personalities. The Grove doesn’t have any monopoly on that class at all.
Also, at any community council meeting it is true that the most active lobbyers are middle class. Yet what do they achieve? Their pleas are full of pre-existing timescales of failure measured in years and are invariably met with promises to “reconsider”.
Take the Forum — essentially its most active committee members are middle class, despite its best efforts and open invitations to participate. Yet what has it achieved, following high level meetings with the Chief Executive, Council Leader and Head of Regeneration all present, on more than one occasion?
The Forum put its finger on it: that Camberwell does not receive its fair share of the capital fund, despite this being assured following the sale of 67 Crawford Road. Yet the lion’s share still went to Dulwich, with a fraction of Camberwell’s problems with crime and anti-social behaviour, and lack of amenities for its residential density.
Then there’s the celebrity marching for the Baths, which according to your logic should be a cinch for the local middle class…
That’s some squeaky wheel, for those who think the oil always goes there. Yet, Dulwich is able to trump this because its councillors happen to constitute the Executive.
Nothing to do with the demographic. Let’s have no pretence that funds for basic services are not being regularly siphoned off to Dulwich to provide parties, balloons and new licks o’ paint.
Regeneguru,
I get the impression that you’ve been around the area for a while and hence can speak with authority. I on the other hand am a relatively new regenepadawan to the area and have not had to content with the many promises and disappointments of the past, so excuse my thoughts as I have much to learn. I have always believed that wholesale regeneration is seldom borne of centralised govt planning, but is in fact something that organically occurs through gentrification. Take Lordship Lane as a case in point. There is no disputing this is an area that has moved from relative impoverishment, to a middle class ‘utopia’ in a relatively short period of time, but I do not believe that the shops, bars and restaurants that have taken to the area have precipitated out of any inspired govt planning, more a general migration from other established London boroughs which are increasingly unaffordable, to a leafy area with a relatively attractive yet affordable housing stock, good schools and easy commute to central London. As the area improves the ‘up and coming’ prophecy becomes increasing self fulfilling, further driving improvement in the area. The same will hopefully become true of Camberwell Grove. With the Mary Datchelor being re-developed a new wave of middle class immigrants (such as myself, truth be told) priced out of surrounding areas will arrive bringing new spending power into the area. I understand that a fear of crime, poor policing and lacking education etc. would hinder this, but as an area gentrifies it begins to generate new council funds and gravitas and can, therefore lobby for improvements. I know this is chicken and egg theory to an extent, but do you believe that local govt has to initiate the process?
Talfourdite
Alan, irrespective of whatever one calls it, I think it’s great area around here. I’ve trapsed all around London for the past 8 years and never really liked anywhere till I came here. Unfortunately, despite my love of the area the Dell Boy, Mandella Estate jokes are the cross you are forced to bear with a SE15 postcode.
Interestingly — given what you observe about LL, Dulwich is still classed as more deprived than Camberwell by the Southwark Executive, despite every independent indicator as to health, deprivation and crime pointing to this as an absurdity.
See also above comments about the capital fund. Camberwell should get back in services and investment what it puts in, but in fact receives far less, not only of basic investment, but even basic services, as these are diverted to Dulwich.
When you have one area that is underresourced, underpoliced and underenforced, all the crap gravitates thereto. That area is Camberwell, surrounded by “regeneration areas” but itself not regenerated. The rape clinic, the drugs clinic, the Maudsley, the alcohol dry-out centre, the street drinkers — you get the picture.
You are right that an area can regenerate itself. It’s what I have always said. But check out the Forum site on http://www.se5forum.org for all the reasons why this hasn’t happened — there’s practically a bible of information from several well-informed locals. Or talk to any SE5 trader, especially outside the immediate area of Camberwell Green, to the North.
How many conversions from amenity to residential have you heard of in Dulwich? Yet here the planners let it happen wholesale, whilst dumping huge influxes of additional residents on ever-spiralling brownfield developments, which bring their cars and all the misery that entails for locals as they block off shops whilst parking then drive to Sainsbury’s to shop outside the area.
The relevant Dulwich Executive officer for Southwark stamped down very heavily indeed on attempts by the Mayor to designate the area as an urban density zone, as we are characterised to our misfortune.
As to gentrification, this can happen in various ways. London is full of areas which have sharply divided rich and poor, and are not pleasant places to live unless the walls are high.
Benhill, thanks, and I agree on your point about leadership. And I must point out that Regeneguru isn’t stuck on parking alone. He has a broad and objective, well informed understanding of the complexities of this area and the dynamics affecting it.
A serious practical problem the Forum has is that everyone involved is already overworked and it doesn’t have a worker to take the planning and administration through from ideas to happening. This is not for a lack of trying to find a good part time worker. None has come forward.
Gnomee — the Forum has had a share of cleaner greener money in the past and is likely to again. Forum inaction isn’t altogether the issue, bringing more skilled or expert opinion to the table would be useful and having a — anyway I’m getting into a chicken and egg spiral here so I’ll stop.
Just picked up this week’s edition of ‘Southwark Weekender’ from the S&D. There is a feature article on Camberwell, which is billed as — wait for it — “The New Hoxton”. Love it!
The erection of a urinal on Camberwell Green is a sign of hope, if you see what I mean. The closure of the Baths, on the other hand, suggests shit outweighs swimming in this green and pleasant land.
Hooray, I got post no. 111.
In Peckham Netto you can buy Starberg lager for £1.11 a litre.
I’m with Flo on this one. And Reg, Dulwich used to be bad. That’s why they got help. That’s why Peckham gets help. We are bad, just not bad enough. But we aren’t good either. So we’re destined to be just what we are.
And cars and parking aren’t going to change that.
The ability to park on Lordship Lane for 30mins is part of the reason for it’s success. I am one of those evil drivers and I love the fact that I know I will be able to park near the relevent shop each time I take a trip to ED. I also use the car park behind Butterfly walk but you need to do the Knowledge to know how to find it.
Free short stay parking is part of the solution.
Spam test — try this post with a different address.
Benhill — I have never said parking was evil. Using words like evil denigrates the debate, so do not use them unless that is your intention.
A specific type of parking is harmful, and not, it is not the only problem (where have I ever said this?).
As Lucas points out, free short stay parking is part of the solution. And yet this solution is incompatible with local resident drivers blocking off access to shops for suppliers and clients for days and weeks on end, by leaving their cars on-street, directly outside shopfronts.
Regeneguru,
Thanks for the link to the SE5 forum. I hadn’t appreciated that there were such a multitude of convoluted power (un)sharing arrangements presiding over Camberwell, such as borough government, policing and neighbourhood renewal to name a few. Clearly this disperate governance seems to to blame for a fair proportion of the members frustrations.
In the face of these many arbitrary divisions perhaps the Camberwell borders should be redrawn, with some areas sacrificed for the goal of cohesive government under Southwark. I cannot imagine the alternative of Lambeth relinquishing its territories, that would be like turkies voting for Christmas.
sorry Dagmar, you have invited me into your home and I have not even marked my possessives correctly — make that “members’ frustrations”.
an iced sh1t sounds pretty evil too, but the imagery enhances the debate undoubtedly. does southwark really consider dulwich more deprived than se5, with a consequent skewing of resources? any evidence of this? as you [reg] say, ludicrous if they do. if camberwell is to be the new hoxton, then the area needs a haircut named after it.
Haircut: The CamberHell Fin
Florian — this year the Southwark Executive decided precisely this, as part of its reasoning for allocating several factors more to Dulwich than Camberwell in leisure centre grants, despite the fact that Camberwell had not even received sufficient maintenance money over a period of decades for its leisure centre.
The sh1t comment described the policies for a geographical area which I like, the evil adjective was ad hominem so kind of interferes with debate. But I am content just to correct the inaccuracy at hand; that I suggested anyone was evil.
Good one, Mark.
I suggest the Camberwell patchy. The barber pulls some hair out by the roots in random areas, and gives grade 0 cuts in small, oddly shaped polygons at selected intervals across the crown. Some parts he allows to grow unchecked over a period of years — it is left to the discretion of the individual how these are combed.
The cut is based on policies of successive Southwark administrations which have neglected Camberwell.
surely the Camberwell Carrot, paying homage to the prodigious creation of Danny in a rare but memorable mention of our homeland. One vertical Mohican spike dyed orange with a green bottom. Alas I can’t really see it catching on, although saying that I was pretty miffed with the resurgence of the mullet.
Talfourdite — welcome to Camberwell, and to the Whirly-gig of campaigning and undeclared interests which constitute the debates hereabouts.
I agree on the mullet. A rise above a certain incidence — say 0.3% of this cut in any region should prompt sudden and emergency European funding, as it is a clear indication of contempt for your fellow man and self, which could lead to a serious disintegration of localist and one-planet values.
Regeneguru, I whole-heartedly concur. I think 0.3% might be a bit high however, if it was an infectious strain and wasn’t contained you could be looking at 1,800,000 mullets in the UK showing the same contempt for basic commonsense, self respect and society at large. Do you think MI5 have envisaged this as a viable, deliberate terrorist threat?
Deep cover MI5 agents have mulleted themselves into oblivion amongst the rest of them.
Regarding the Willow closing — it would help if restaurants in Camberwell bothered to open at the weekend. If you walk through Camberwell on a Sunday afternoon, it’s like a neutron bomb hit the place. All the restaurants are closed except for Nando’s. And they never seem to be able to fix their fizzy drink machine. Groan.
Same for weekend breakfast. We roamed around for ages once.
Cafe in Burgess Park good. But (breaking news?) they are closing down and moving! Some fight with the Council.
Where to get a good breakfast before noon of a Sunday?
@126 — Don’t know whether this is some kind of freak coincidence, but the police seem also to operate a weekday service only in SE5.
Then again, this could be an unrelated Camberwellism.
Go figure!