I took a walk around the Green this morning and the sight of the Magistrates Court reminded me that I was going to write something about the proposal to move the library. As you may or may not know, Southwark Council have an 8,000 sq. ft. prefabricated building in Bermondsey which is now unused, and they’re considering moving it to the plaza in front of the Court and using it to house the library (currently on Church St.), a meeting space, and cafe. You can see the plans in this consultation document [PDF].
The Camberwell Society object to the proposal on the grounds that the building’s just too big; it would occupy most of the currently open plaza, making it very cramped, and involve cutting down some of the orchard (which they say is ‘becoming lovely’, although I’d dispute that) and some and nearby trees. Also, planning permission was granted only last year for children’s play resources and tree re-planting.
They say the move is likely to cost somewhere in the region of £500,000, and the building itself has an estimated life span of only 10 years, so would rather see the money spent on developing the existing library and meeting spaces in the leisure centre. There would also be costs involved in breaking the leases that are held on the current property.
I received an email from someone suspecting ‘ulterior motives’ for the Council’s proposal, and the author has some questions that they feel haven’t been answered, including:
- Has an application for planning permission been made?
- What is the total projected cost of the move?
- Have estimates been made for repairs to the existing building?
- What will be done with the old building?
Someone on this blog mentioned a Tesco opening in the current library’s position, but I’m not sure if that was any more than a joke or speculation.
I have to say that I’m not against this proposal if it brings benefits, but I agree that the proposal for meeting spaces and cafe could easily be met by funding the leisure centre, in which case moving the library doesn’t seem to make much sense.
The Council are running the public consultation until 21 April; download a copy [PDF] and fill in your responses if you’re interested in making your voice heard.

@Frazzle: “by AV you have to list 2nd,3,4,5th prefernce” — as James J says, no you don’t. You can vote for one candidate only if only one appeals to you, or first and second if that’s your choice. You can vote for as many as you like, in order of preference.
“if AV worked, a lot more countries would be using it” — The most popular democratic system is Proportional Representation, but as I understand it the Conservatives refused to accept this as an option when the coalition was being formed; make of that what you will.
@lili — “here’s a suggestion for se5 forum” — you can be given admin privileges if you have ideas to take SE5 Forum forwards.
@peter: thanks peter, i just don’t have any free time left at all, plenty to do with people’s republic of southwark alone
the idea was more to open a discussion about whether others feel that this might be a good thing — public communication is i think desperately needed and this could be a fairly effortless and certainly inexpensive way of doing it (as no community council meeting will ever either attract or, more importantly, allow proper conversations)
x
I am voting YES; Because it’s the right way to vote.
@Lili. Good timing; SE5 Forum has been musing that very point and had a meeting recently with Southwark and among other things there was a discussion about communication. Exactly the points you touch on were brought up and The SE5 Forum site will be adapted to make the discussion board more prominent and we’re looking to make part of it over to a dialogue between the people and the representatives…
Saw Buster Martin’s funeral cortege on Camberwell New Road heading towards Camberwell this morning. Reminded me of his fight at the Fox on the Hill — http://bit.ly/JPvMf.
RIP Buster
I am voting YES
I shall be voting yes
@mark: brilliant. wonder if i should set up a psychic shop? 🙂 xxx
I saw his London Marathon cortege crossing tower Bridge in 2008, provided by Pimlico Plumbers — the blue vans with the cloaca related licence plates.
You don’t need a polling card, just go to your church /school, and give them your address
Tricky this AV thing. After studying Arrow’s theorem then the Gibbard-Satterthwaite theorem plus the Farquarson-Dummet conjecture coming up on the inside rail like a Lib-Dem waving a new good idea on a piece of A4, we are deep into decision theory, with a choice between cardinal utility and ordinary utility — Catholics would expect to see the second choice of utility to be venial utility or for there to be the dreaded mortal utility; socialists may hope to see public utility.
The New Statesman talks about “the paucity of arguments for FPTP” but that AV “is not a panacea”. Paucity? Panacea? Pardon?
The Guardian bring in a mathematician to help explain — he is called David Broomhead. Sweeping all doubts before him? No, raising even more questions, especially because he says AV will not get rid of tactical voting. Old Broomhead!
Labour MPs for AV include Harriet & Jack, Oona King, Diana Abbott and Joan Ruddock, also Benn pere et fils, Neil and Glenys, Gordon Brown and the MEP Michael Cashman (the pioneering gay Colin from Eastenders, a good egg).
Significantly, Jon Cruddas, Left-of-centre top thinker, MP for Dagenham and Rainham, who won the highest proportion of votes in the Labour Deputy Leadership election but eventually lost to Harriet, supports AV.
David Plonkett, talking of the argy-bargy that’s been going on between the yes and no campaigns, has said: “We are in danger of descending into the politics of the playground.”
The what? That piece of complete incomprehension says don’t vote at all or for for people like him and the Millipedes for whom politics (“pollicy” and “pollitics”) is the first-past-the-post concern of every genuine human person.
Tricky, this one.
And here comes Peter Mandelson, the man from Del Monte — he say yes.
IT’S SIMPLE. if there’s a complicated system, people won’t vote.
I was astonished to see that the S&D became a seething bed of political activism last night. Some of those placards were waved in a very aggressive way.
Free schools have been with us for donkey’s years. Once they were the exclusive domain of impoverished hippy parents, all wooly jumpers and sandals. Only the Guardian took them seriously.
Now that they have been embraced by the tories, free schools are viewed as the lovechild of the fascist right. Grey-suited profiteer head teachers cherry-picking pupils from behind the smoked glass of their sinister black BMWs.
The reality is probably somewhere in the middle, and probably always has been.
Yes of course, any kind of selective school is divisive. Whether it’s selective by fees, faith or specialist interest, by definition it’s takes a slice of potential pupils guided by it’s own criteria.
But we’ve always chosen our own tribe, in school, in work, in life. So it goes.
Encouraging a free school with a larger than average contribution of public funds is morally wrong. It’s the finance system that’s wrong, not the concept.
The fact remains that many (all?) education authorities are unable to offer the choice that has been dangled in front of parents. Choice was never a realistic option for most of us and it was dishonest of successive governments to offer it.
In the meantime, parents are mostly unable to opt out of the process. “Oh, this education system is crap at the moment. I’ll wait ten years until it’s better and then my kids can go to school.” Hmmmmm.
The Anti Academies Alliance, in it’s rather Anti Swedish polemic, assumes that free schools are created only to generate profit. Try telling that to the sandal-wearers of the second paragraph.
The only real option is to work within the system, warts and all. People have a knack of usurping politicians aspirations and producing unexpected outcomes.
Perhaps free schools will be a genuine reflection of the tribes that create them. Free of political dogma maybe free schools will produce broad, free-thinking citizens. Perhaps self-righteous indignation will become a thing of the past. It’s too early to say that free schools won’t work.
Blimey, what a long post. Sorry.
Not an endorsement, but here is a write up of last night’s free school meeting by the Anti-Academies Alliance.
http://fb.me/JKaLe4FY
Are there any secondary schools that aren’t academies left in this area? These days, pretty much every secondary school is either an academy or has specialist status for something, which similarly allows them to tap into additional funding. This suggests that the Anti-Academies Alliance don’t have much influence with school governors or headteachers.
Dagmar, you couldn’t vote in the referendum, could you? I note that Denmark doesn’t use FPTP, but a constituency system with proportional top-up. Doubtless too complicated for us.
The Telegraph’s James Delingpole was at the meeting too. He calls the anti-free school campaigners ‘evil’:
http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/jamesdelingpole/100086787/free-schools-the-stake-in-the-heart-of-the-progressive-vampire/
Not sure he can be trusted though. He says the Sun and Doves is in Brixton.
My, what a deeply unpleasant person Mr Delingpole seems. Just reading his article drove me to have a shower.
The forces of the dark empire have seized free schools as a mantra. Can the wishy-washy left have it back please.
Looks like the lefty parts of central London, including Lambeth and Southwark, have voted yes to AV. Won’t change the huge defeat on a national level.
The free school meeting was extremely interesting and it was good that the Sun & Doves gave the steering committee, as they style themselves, a chance to reveal themselves.
They really should go ahead and set up their school, but not with public money. They should just set up a good, honest, private school. The customers they attract and impress are cash rich, after all.
This is a very complex subject and not one for jokey tittle tattle here. However, the situation for parents round these parts for placing their kids in secondary education is not great.
And it is for this reason that I have to tell you now, that my next excursion in these pages will be to dismantle Mr Delingpole’s hastily and nastily scribbled piece, bit by bit, before I am tempted to do the same to his person.
James Delingpole’s article must surely be a piece of anti-propaganda for the Free School idea, no? Caricaturing Lambeth Council as stridently left-wing might go down well in wibbly-wobbly world that comprises large parts of The Telegraph’s readership, but really!
In an article where the writer poses as the defender of top-class education, I would have expected better than;
“.….the activist mob who tried to hijacked”.… & “…which will be open to all, regardless of race or religious domination.…”
Spellcheck wouldn’t pick up either of those, I suppose. And, it appears, realitycheck also failed in filtering out some of the more poisonous opinions in the rest of the article. I for one can’t swallow that responsibility for knife crime, unemployment levels & benefit dependency can all be laid at the door of Southwark & Lambeth’s state secondary schools.
Delingpole, Littlejohn, Toynbee, Hari — all about hyperbole and playing fast and loose with the facts to fire up the hard left or hard right. Criticise one, criticise all.
And yay for the ‘no’ victory, though I am sure I am “stupid and misinformed” for having rejected “yes”
@ Camberwell Green Farmer’s Market w/ a few others. Veg chilli for £4.
The price of flour must have hit the roof I just paid 2.80 for a loaf bread at the market, and the price of salmon.…dear dear!
Those of you interested in education should watch this animated lecture by Sir Ken Robinson. Only 10 minutes, very interesting.
http://youtu.be/zDZFcDGpL4U
Super link Peter.
I’ve been thinking about posting about the meeting about the new school but there seemed too many ifs and abouts about it so held off until now and now I’m still not sure what to say.
You might be right David.
What else links the ten areas that voted yes?
I have yet to find a good analysis of this…
Oxford, Cambridge, Hackney, Lambeth, Southwark, Camden, Islington, Haringey, Glasgow Kelvin and Edinburgh Central.
And what went wrong in Central Cardiff and Central Belfast?
Cardiff central was a near miss and Northern Ireland was a single area so that gives us a clue…
Alan Dale@
Could Universities — and the areas where there are a high percentage of students living (ie:due to lower rents) be a factor in what connect all the areas which voted Yes?
A lot of post-graduates (young-ish professionals?) live in those areas too…The arts led economic renaissance of Hackney is a case in point…
Just a thought
That certainly fits in with David’s theory that he wasn’t clever enough to vote yes!
Here are some of the steering group for the new school: http://bit.ly/ixzbUs
I think we gave a really good account of the proposition at the Sun and Doves’ meeting. The Q&A had to be brought to a close because it was clear that it was about to turn into a shouting aggressive anti Free School propaganda opportunity by a bunch of uninformed protestors we had the good nature to allow into the meeting. If their tone had been one of discourse instead of loud and filled with invective it would have continued in open session. Instead the audience were able to ask steering group members one to one about the proposal and the teachers who had come from secondary schools as far away as Croydon, considering applying for a job, were able to find out more directly. One prospective parent couple left in tears shortly after the meeting was called down, saying “I can’t understand why people who disagree with this have to be so aggressive, all we want is for our children to get into a school that’s not going to ruin their lives”.
It was emotional. I well up each time I describe what happened to one of my eldest son’s classmates — the one who didn’t get a place at all — and it was no different explaining how I came to be involved in the steering group from the outset in front of a hundred or so people in my own back garden. I’m totally behind this happening. I’m NOT a Tory and this is NOT a Tory plot. It’s for ordinary people and, Dagmar, the people most interested in putting their kids down for a place at Michaela Community School CANNOT afford a private place anywhere. This is NOT about privatisation by the back door it’s about providing a state funded school that actually works in an area that is patently desperately short of places.
http://www.michaelacommunityschool.co.uk sign up there…
alan dale@
I was just observing…not accusing anybody of being stupid.
By that rationale, then I was too stupid to vote yes, because I didn’t go to uni either 😉
I just thought it was a slightly better idea than what we have at the moment …
In reality it’s the entire economic machine which needs to change — not the way we vote.
@Peter — the link in your earlier posting is really thought-provoking — thanks.
@Mark — your last posting is also much appreciated.
OK, so here is James Delingpole’s list of cartoony stereotypes from the free school steering committee at the Sun & Doves meeting last week, exactly cut-and-pastedly like this:
“… a snappy Asian private equity man who’s taking care of the financial side; a white publican in tears at the misery the progressive system had inflicted on his kids; a young white schoolteacher outlining a curriculum brimming with rigour and Oxbridge aspiration; Tony Sewell, built like a black heavyweight boxer, talking unapologetically about elitism; the white, fiery Oxbridge-educated head of maths talking about the extra, private-school-style late afternoon classes which over five years will add up to a whole extra years’ worth of education; then Katharine Birbalsingh herself in her lovely lilting Guyanan accent enthusing about the school in a way you just know is going to make her one of the best headteachers in the country.”
Tony Sewell was great as it happens, though Our ‘Enery and Our ‘Ali might take issue with the stereotype that he is “built like a black heavyweight boxer.” He is much more like a large and experienced educationalist and does not have to be described as “black” or like a boxer. Dear oh dear. He may have been handy 20 years ago, but he ain’t no Sonny Liston now. He is a solid, good bloke, full of good, surprising, bang-on, really nice ideas.
Why can’t he be put forward as the head? Look at what he writes in the Guardian. He’s good. Everyone can relate to him. Why does the head have to be Birbalsingh, who is obviously completely tonto — “lovely lilting Guyanan accent”? Dear oh dear. She will piss off everyone in the school from the lollypop man downwards on Day One.
She was strident. Being strident is not where’s it’s at. Say no to strident. Tony wasn’t strident. The anti-crowd were strident. That harpie! Greenham Common is over there love, calm down, dear. OK, here’s a knife, cut his bollocks off, then, if it makes you feel better.
That big, Bob Crowe bloke was a cropped-haired bruiser stereotype all right — would have lost to Tony in the first round, though. When whichever steering committer said that 50% of world leaders had been to Oxford, he shouted “Rubbish!” — he should have just left a silence, but he interrupted the dickhead, the fatuous thug, with some old WRP snake-bite froth blather.
There was no need to be all workerist and horrible.
Still, what IS all this from the steerage committee about Oxford? They kept going on: Oxford, Oxford, Oxford. They then brought on that charming lad as an example of a black young feller who was in his first year studying medicine — but he was at London. How humiliating. What a second-rater. Poor lad. Except he was good, like Tony, too.
Everyone knows that Oxford is full of posh, bumbling dumbos. Anyone who really knows, knows that really intelligent people go to CAMBRIDGE. Duh.
Some huge amount of money may well be taken from local secondary schools to fund the new school. Mark Dodds did well to give the steering committee — some of them Oxford-educated failed Tory general election candidates — a good hearing.
If the school goes ahead, that will show what Cameron, Osborne and the rest of the greased-mop cru are made of. It really will be a test of their judgement.
In the meantime, we should support Tony Sewell and hope he gets his liberty away from those cowboys.
Where is Harriet Harman? Camberwell’s local MP may well, like Mrs Jellyby in Dickens’ Bleak House, worry about the poor Africans in the land of Borrioboola-gah. But what about our own?
Life years ago in the Rift Valley was not great. But we were ALL IN IT TOGETHER.
Oxford can’t be that bad seeing as how they voted yes.
This private/free school has a bit of an Oxford and Cambridge fetish. It’s putting me off a bit. GCSEs and A‑Levels are where it’s at.
Also, I can understand surrounding schools being concerned about the new free school. Won’t it absorb resources and aspiring families/children in the same way the private sector does now?
But the current situation is failing the entire area and many generations of school children have not had a fair shake.
So I don’t know what should be done.
No Gabe, GCSEs and A levels aren’t where it’s at.
Education is where it’s at. Broad-minded, fair, free-thinking young people generous in spirit and action is where it’s at.
Parents demanding quantities of GCSE and A level labels have created the current fouled up system, where children and young people who fail to reach some magic number are considered second-class.
I watched the video clip that has raved about on here.
Some sense in there but a fair dose of nonsense too.
I am glad I didn’t spend school brainstorming alternative paper clip uses as a group. If that’s broad minded free thinkin education then I prefer GCSEs.
Glad I wasn’t drugged for dossing about mind!
Jes, I get your point, for sure.
“Broad-minded, fair, free-thinking young people generous in spirit and action is where it’s at.”
Ideally, you get to that partly through formal, academic education. But without the A‑Level, it’s harder to get the college place, and harder to make better money later in life. Not impossible, but harder.
A big problem in the local schools is that not enough children are educated to a high enough standard of GCSE or A‑Level.
The kids themselves seem smart enough. I don’t think that’s the problem.
Either
1) Define a ‘genius’ as someone who thinks that something 600ft high and made of rubber could be a paper clip.
2) Discover that as children go through the education system there are fewer ‘geniuses’.
3) Conclude that education is in crisis and a new paradigm is required.
Or
1) Define a paper clip as something usually about an inch long and made of metal.
2) Discover that as children go through the education system most of them learn what a paper clip is.
3) Conclude that the education system is in an alright shape, but something should probably be done about those kids leaving school who still have no idea what a paper clip is.
am i just mis-reading the signs, but are southwark council really planning to close the entire of burgess park for 8 (read much longer) months.….except the cafe.… from the end of this month?
Just went to the Hermit. They really need to dim their white lighting.
@Paul B
That’s pretty much right. Most of the park is closing soon until spring next year. Some of the extremities, such as the Surrey Canal Walk, Addington Square, and the bits over towards the Old Kent Road will stay open. All the sports facilities and the children’s adventure playground will also stay open.
I live right next to the park and use it almost every day. It’s going to change a lot of my routines. But, I’m still on balance positive about the plans for the park and the closure is something I can accept.
At the last Friends of Burgess Park open meeting, which was last Tuesday, the head of parks at Southwark Council explained why it had to be done this way. They realise it’s not ideal, but trying to keep areas of the park open or zoning the work would add massively to the costs (we’re talking mid to high £100 000s out of a £6 million budget) and rightly they’d rather spend this money on making improvements the park.
This Saturday is the Burgess Park May Fair. In the evening, there will be an outdoor screening of Slumdog Millionaire. Come and enjoy the park before it closes. There will be information on the day about the plans for the park. Details here:
http://www.friendsofburgesspark.org.uk/index.html
What will happen to Carnavale Del Pueblo this summer then?
Ten years from now in the revitalised Burgess Park, Del Pueblo will be bigger than Notting Hill. You heard it!
It will be in Brockwell Park.
WE will put together a fact sheet that lays out the basics about the School we are proposing setting up. It should answer a lot of questions and fears about Free Schools and open the questions up to more specific issues that can be dealt with simply.
Here is another shameless publicity photograph of the group:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/markdodds/5709212607/in/photostream
To be fair to Ken Robinson, and to be fair to the steering group of the Michaela Community School it’s not about paper clips and it’s not about Oxford per se and by the way the references made in the pub garden — to standards the school will stimulate children to aspire to — were to Oxbridge / Russell Group universities of which Kings College London, where Chidi is studying medicine, is a member.
These allusions are aimed at describing what a good education should do to the development of people’s mind. A competent education should exercise and broaden the mind’s scope, not restrict its flexibility and imaginative remit — which is what our education system seems does rather well for most people.
My own experience is that I was bored rigid for most of my school years. I didn’t go to bad schools; it’s just the way education was done was bad for me. And for most of my classmates. It worked fine for those of us who just seemed naturally to fire on all academic cylinders. Which I guess was about ten percent of us. The rest of us were just bulking agent for the school’s performance ratings.
Education education education.
I stopped watching television daily/nightly as a matter of course about twenty years ago and stopped reading newspapers around the same time. I found they were bombarding me with too much stuff, made me fascinated in stuff I didn’t want to know about, made me feel like I was a massive underachiever, and made me feel frustrated and depressed.
A year long course with this outfit helped make me feel like I was finding myself again:
http://www.commonpurpose.org.uk/
They are naturally hated by people who believe in conspiracy theories:
http://www.stopcp.com/
The kind of people who remind me of some of the people who were in the picket line last week but at the other end of the political spectrum who promote this sort of thing:
http://www.antiacademies.org.uk/Home/free-schools
http://www.antiacademies.org.uk/Home/free-schools
Really James? Or just a sensible guess?
I would have thought it more likely to be in Southwark Park than to move to Lambeth…