In the traditional ‘burying bad news’ time slot (I hope that’s not ominous), Southwark Council have released the two shortlisted proposals for Burgess Park.
I’ve hardly had time to look at these myself, yet, so reaction will follow.
Update: So here’s my considered opinion. Obviously with a constrained budget (£6m may sound a lot, but Burgess Park is one of the largest in London and is receiving a fraction of the money given to comparable projects) both have had to be somewhat cautious in their plans; it’s quite funny to see existing features marketed as new ones (“a wide tree-lined avenue along the historical canal path, with space for walkers, runners and cyclists” — that’s what we have now, only with not so many trees).
As well as improved entrances and lighting, which were requirements, both have focussed on the lake area and a new public square where the underpass currently sits; as both have proposed sealing the underpass, this does present the problem of having a very busy road run through the middle of it and no easy way to cross; a minus point, in my book.
Gillespies bid is the more cautious (sensible?) of the two; I liked their dog-only areas, cycling/walking routes, and meadow area.
LDA Designs were more ambitious; informative art pieces are respectful of the park’s history, and with more biodiversity — including a wetlands area and an orchard.
Of the two, I think I lean towards the latter (I will have to assume that everything they’ve planned can be achieved within the budget), but it’s very close.
Went to the Bear and Silk Road recently. Success has changed both.
On Friday night The Bear was the busiest I’ve ever seen it. The first few times I ate there we were one of about 3 tables and service was great. With all the tables full the charming service really struggled, and it started to get on my nerves. Had to ask them to clear plates, ask for more drinks, ask for the dessert menu etc. Food was great as usual — pork belly, lentils and a delightful boudin noir — but if they don’t up the staff numbers I won’t be rushing back.
Silk Road. Most times I’ve been here it’s been overrun with loud groups of young Chinese. Now, perhaps with the Observer effect, the demographic has shifted markedly. That doesn’t affect the food of course, which was hearty and generous. However, once over the novelty of the few Xinjiang dishes (pilaf rice was a new one for me this time, and the fried noodles were great as per) you have to question whether the Chinese dishes are that good. The bak choi weren’t as crispy as they once were here, and the pork was too sweet, and swimming in grease. I think in some instances you’d be better off with a good Chinese restaurant instead.
Both of these experiences left me with that strange, slightly selfish irritation you get of having “found” somewhere early on and then when half of London catches on it’s not as good, somehow less authentic, whatever that means. So while it’s pleasing that these places are doing well and aren’t going to be boarded up shells on our high street, it’s also not. Oh well, onto the next thing…
@ Camberwell Experiment
Good luck to PRoS. Most Camberwell-wide community organisations before it have suffered from having a majority of members who are white, upper middle class, property owning, car owning, and South-Camberwell-dwelling — a fatal combination from the perspective of deprived North Camberwell areas.
Camberwell’s main problem is that too many people leave it, and not enough visit it, to spend money. Also that policy-makers and campaigners either do not accept that most disposable income travels by car, or pretend not to see this in order to protect their own lifestyles of regular escape from Camberwell.
This response by Morrisons to the Core Strategy was interesting. The outdated retail report referred to can be found here. Note paragraph 6.3 on comparison goods.
Of course, planners have interpreted the dictat that there should be no new shops outside certain areas to mean that all retail activity outside these areas should cease. An approach which affects Camberwell more than any other area. The future health of Camberwell Green itself depends heavily on the development of a local shopping culture in outer Camberwell, sustained in part by visiting trade as in Lordship Lane.
oh noes i hope extreme glaring and use of long words are still legal?
thanks, phil g & regen
question: do we know what happens at the council’s planning meetings? i tried looking at things a couple of times in the past but just could not stay awake long enough to process any of the information :S
i mean, i know that planning applications are discussed, but what i’d like to know is whether potential spaces are discussed at any public meetings before they are passed onto developers to propose whatever they’re told to. i think having timely access to this information would be very important. thanks
@Royal Mail
There is a sparkling new alternative to the Post Office/ couriers I found this weekend. It’s called Collect Plus, and is really rather ingenious for parcel delivery.
Imagine you’re sending an eBay parcel to the Highlands — normal courier cost about £18, plus you have to be in all day when the courier collects, and your buyer has to be in all day until the courier delivers their end. Well now for the bargain price of £3.79 you can use Collect Plus.
This involves taking your package (max 10kg) to a local convenience store whenever you like (3000+ locations UK-wide, nearest one to me is half a mile away on Coldharbour Lane towards Brixton). It gets picked up and delivered to a convenience store near the recipient — in my case, 0.37 miles away in the local petrol station. Which of course means the buyer can pick up the parcel when they like, and at hours much more convenient than a local Post Office depot.
To me, this is the essence of progress.
http://www.collectplus.co.uk/
Not that I is bovvered, but Mark Steel offers a pointed analysis of industrial relations in the post office.
http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/mark-steel/mark-steel-royal-mail-is-to-blame-for-our-broken-society-obviously-1806199.html
@Dagamar (10/23/2009 at 7:41 pm) — you should write for the Internet.
Oh wait…
On restaurants, Ganapati was quiet Saturday night, although apparently only because I was there between sittings. Food was good as normal.
On the leisure center, you have go around the back to get in nowadays. The front is being refurbed. Can someone ask them to turn the heating down?
On art galleries, there’s a video exhibition at SLG (yes another one). It’s very dark in there. I sort of got it, I think. Not sure.
Gabe, is Dagmar here, not Dagamar. The Indian summer is here as the thugees say in old India. As the Dalai Lama says, there is no us and them any more, due to the internet, etc. Still, maybe in India they would like a British winter, with snow and jollity.
SLG show takes a lot of looking, it’s true, but at least it is there and truly cool.
Whoops, a tyupo.
Or Dagmar meet Dagamar, maybe. nah.
“Tis nothing. What a tropical day in Lucas Gardens. The mushroom people are out, some looking for the funny ones, some for the gourmet ones. Does anyone know if part of the park is being sold with the council buildings? Rumours persist that a sizeable chunk will be sold off. The residents would be sitting ducks, sipping their G&T, with people peering in, deprived of a large part of their park.
we wrote about it back in may this year here http://www.peoplesrepublicofsouthwark.co.uk/news/lucas-gardens-executive-style#at
i’ll try and get in touch with the people from wilson’s tra to see what’s going on
x
SE% Forum AGM tomorrow night at Institute of Psychiatry, De Crespigny Park.
IF you are concerned about Camberwell do come along and take it on. You will be amazed what can be achieved with concerted effort.
http://www.se5forum.org/
The environmental impact of owning a large dog is comparable to having a large 4WD and driving 10,000km.
Too short notice for the Forum tonight, sorry I can’t make it. Annoying as I’d like to go see. Please sort the Noodles sign.
Short notice and poor show SE5 Forum!
I get an email TODAY informing me of a meeting TONIGHT. it shows all email addresses, which is highly annoying. And now I am in a reply all cycle!
Poor show!
Two Johns?; Camberwell Blog goes global
Sorry. Had one of those “we need to move out of this place” weeks and then a chance to try and do something positive comes along too late and shares my personal data so I freaked out. Anyone go?
yes i did, it was a pretty straightforward agm, with the usual agm business, john stewart of lambeth transport group (i think) did a little q&a session about the save the south london line campaign, as boris has finally agreed to meet up with the deputation.
one of the things we (people’s republic of soutwhark) will be pushing though is a campaign to urgently do something about camberwell town centre (which lies beyond camberwell grove and includes camberwell new road, camberwell road etc); ‘something’ means considerably more than making sure that facades are in keep with the conservation area requirements; it may also mean that yet another shop may not be on top of the list of priorities for hundreds of deprived people living on the other side of camberwell green.
a lot of the people living in the area are keen to improve their surroundings. a lot of the people have really good ideas too, and real positive change could happen. it would be great if se5 forum was to formally get behind this too, as i know those board members i spoke to are keen, so i guess we wait and see?
Moral quandary: I’d like to join the London Fitness Network which gives access to many council gyms across London, and thus one near my work.
To do so I would have to enrol and pay monthly fees to a council gym, even if it’s one I don’t use often. Peckham is my nearest. But I was a member there for 2 years and found it an awful, truly shytt place with the world’s laziest staff. I am loathe to give the money to them as it would up their income and numbers.
So, I may join at East Dulwich, but then the cash still goes to Southwark and the awful company they’ve outsourced leisure to — Fusion.
Or I could join through Camden council and make things more expensive for the same scheme by paying a higher joining fee.
Or I could recognise that keeping the money local would ultimately be better than giving it to Camden out of spite, and go back to Peckham, humbled.
Check this out, it seems the place has long been awful.
http://www.southwark.gov.uk/SouthwarkDiscussion/ShowPost.aspx?PostID=794
Here is some blue sky thinking: The pedestrianisation of the western end of Camberwell Church Street.
http://j.mp/224gt4
It wouldn’t cost much and would have a revolutionary affect on Camberwell. It would also help motorists because it would relieve congestion by splitting traffic while also shortening journeys on more suitable roads. The proposal would also speed-up bus journeys and would help make cycling safer. Most importantly it would vastly improve the living environment around Camberwell.
What do you think?
from what i gather, it’d be a partial pedestrianisation, as buses would still be running? unless i got it all wrong?
last night at the se5 forum agm, someone said how the camberwell church street/peckham road is the major lorry route to dover and is allegedly untouchable. i dont think anything is personally and i would very much love to see bits of roads closed off to all but cyclists and pedestrians.
last year we were talking to people about the festival of everything, where the idea was to close the whole of camberwell road/walworth road for traffic, for one day only, bring all the communities on either sides of the road out together, lawn a stretch of the road and just have a picnic etc etc, and while there was a lot of enthusiasm from the artistic community in the area, the council people didnt feel the tfl would be up for discussions.
last week, the australian government turned a whole road in sydney i think into one massive picnic area and thousands of people came down to have breakfast (twas on the beeb somewhere, cant find it anymore)
NickW, The details of that pedestrianisation plan are ill-thought through. Camberwell Church St. has its problems, but it would be absurd to divert traffic on to a narrower street with more serious problems. Southampton Way is a relatively narrow road that passes through an almost entirely residential area. The few local shops are already in a state of serious decline and the last thing it needs is heavier traffic and congestion. Wyndham Road is all residential except for the secondary school. Albany Road is large enough for traffic, but it is already congested, and is it ideal to direct more traffic down a road that runs between a park, a large estate, a school, a sure start children’s centre, an adventure play ground etc?
You really can’t solve Camberwell’s problems by pushing the traffic onto smaller roads. You need to consider the area as a whole not just central Camberwell. The solution has to lie in reducing overall traffic levels by reducing the unnecessary use of private cars, shifting journeys onto public transport or bicycle.
found it!
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/8324527.stm
@ James J
Hi James,
Thanks for the comments.
Let me answer your points:
Southampton Way has far less residential housing than Peckham Road, Camberwell Church Street and the eastern end of Camberwell New Road combined. It also has far fewer shops than Camberwell Church Street. The housing on Southampton way is predominantly newer and has better sound insulation. Without on street parking, or need for bus lane, the road is the same width or wider. The section of affected road is shorter and the shops may actually benefit from more passing trade. The proposal would mean only local traffic using this road. There would be need for remodeling and loss of on street parking however even in the short term the number of people benefiting, I believe, would be far greater while in the long term an improved town centre would improve the whole area.
Wyndham Road – Yes this is currently a residential road and remodeling would be required including the loss of on street parking, however the residential housing here is predominantly newer, better sound insulated and set someway back from the road or above the road in blocks. I believe the road to be more suitable to traffic than the current route. (This is also the case with John Ruskin Street)
Albany Road – as you identified is currently suitable with little remodeling. The number of pedestrians crossing here is far less than the current route through a town centre.
I did look at the wider area and put some work into this vision. The main relief route via John Ruskin Street and Albany road to the far more suitable A2 is two thirds shorter than the current A202 route which passes through 3 town centers (Peckham, Camberwell and New Cross). The proposed route passes through 0 town centers.
AH wow Liliana – that is inspirational.
I’m afraid I don’t accept your description of Southampton Road. It is a narrow road, certainly much narrower than Peckham Road and Camberwell Church Street. There is very little on street parking on most of Southampton Way, precisely because it is narrow. In contrast, the Camberwell Church St./Peckham Road route is effectively a four lane road. When the 343 stops at a bus stop it will block traffic on that side of the road. Furthermore, without any parking, increased traffic will not be of any benefit to the local shops.
As for the quantity of residential accommodation, I am not able to quote numbers. However, once the Elmington Estate redevelopment gets under way, the entire route from Camberwell Road to Peckham Road will be residential apart from the small industrial estate at Parkhouse Street (which the council would like to convert to residential use in the long term), the Southwark College campus and the Oliver Goldsmith Primary School.
The case for Wyndham Road is even worse. It is currently traffic calmed to stop people using it as a short cut. Directing traffic past a school is a recipe for accidents.
Really, I think the solution has to be something other than shifting traffic on to smaller roads. For example, why are international coaches travelling into central London anyway? Why not stop them somewhere with good transport links outside of the centre. Perhaps somewhere like Stratford, with coaches travelling on the A13 to the Dartford Tunnel and then the motorway to the coast.
James — It would only be local traffic going down Southampton Way. The current route, HGVs and all, passes schools as well eg. Sacred Heart.
Regarding width — Camberwell New Road is of course wider there are 4 lanes however what I am saying is you wouldn’t need 4 lanes as you don’t need the bus lanes, the two lanes on Southampton road would be fine with some extra local traffic probably not even that much. I don’t have stats but by looking at the traffic on Church Street — buses, foreign coaches and HGV it is fairly easy to deduce that most of it is long distance and so would therefore be diverted another way.
Re the 343 – it stops is every 15mins that’s 4 buses an hour. I am sure local traffic can wait behind the bus as it currently does.
We are not talking about ALL the coaches and lorries and buses that all travel down Camberwell Church Street at present but fairly distributing a portion of the local traffic away from where the largest concentration of people live work and shop.
I like your bus terminal idea but this is not something that can be achieved locally. It doesn’t stop the lorries and it means an extra change for people. Listen the project needs more work and professional eyes but current situation around Camberwell Green cannot continue. It is one of the noisiest junctions in London.
Nick, The 343 is certainly supposed to be more often than that: every 6–7 min according to londonbusroutes.net but that’s complicated by the fact they do tend to travel in groups of two or three.
It’s good that you are giving this some thought. Sorry, if I’ve sounded very negative, but I’m afraid I’m not convinced by the plan. Anyway, perhaps I’m in a minority. It’s shame that the funding isn’t available for the kind of project that might really solve the problem, but in fact even the plan to pedestrianise Camberwell Church St. is out of the hands of Southwark as it is a Red Route and thus controlled centrally by TfL not by the council. It’s the same issue with Elephant & Castle and the Bricklayer’s Arms flyover.
NickW — impressive research and detail, although I disagree with the main thrust for similar reasons to James J. For a fuller response, including why it would be very bad for cyclists, see here.
Interesting idea Nick but I think it’s unworkable, for the reasons above and more. I hate the volume of traffic on Peckham Rd but don’t think your solution would help. Also I think pedestrianisation as a concept is overrated. Sorry, I don’t have the answers either. Old infrastructure quite unable to deal with modern volume. That’s London.
So anyway, was in Peckham Morrisons today and some African bloke comes up to me and asks if I speak French.
How charming I thought! This middle aged chap, perhaps from the Cote d’Ivoire or Senegal, is going to ask me ou est le shampooing, or pourquoi is food anglais so vraiment expensive.
I was delighted. Interaction with another human in Peckham Morrisons at last! And in French! Surely this was multicultural life in the capital!
I replied that yes I speak OK French and he smilingly continued:
“Then perhaps you could help me, there’s a bag of my things over there (he waved at some mysterious point a few aisles away) and I just need one pound to be able to buy it all. If you could help me by giving me a pound…”
Has anyone tried what used to be the Peckham Experiment now may be called Bellenden Brasserie, though I can’t remember the name. Any good?
It appears to have shut down. It was taken over a few months ago purporting to be an African restaurant. But it rarely seems open, certainly not at lunch. Shame because it was once a good place to eat.
I see the Silver Buckle is being offered for lease — http://www.pub-enterprises.co.uk/pages/PubDetails?pp360divid=PubDetails-body-right&pp360divsrc=/__80256825005C84E2.nsf/%28webPubByPropertyRef%29/A70F1CCB76D10C728025763800423F6E%3FOpenDocument — just imagine for the initial investment of £21,000 or so you could be running one of Camberwell’s top pub venues!
Speaking of pubs the Grand Union on Camberwell Grove (formerly The Grove/BRB/Grove House) I see is opening on Thursday http://www.gugroup.co.uk/content/camberwell.html
Launch party — http://us1.campaign-archive.com/?u=4a3bf5e6882abe7172d3c4ab2&id=cb6278a077
Had burger and chips at the Brixton G.U. this weekend. Lovely. Seems more likely to succeed then the previous Grove effort (which seemed to be aimed at retirees), especially as the gourmet burgers are good value.
My reflex is to favour any scheme to improve the central Camberwell landscape and improve transport links. But since we chose to splurge a trillion quid of our money re-inflating asset bubbles, we may have to wait. When my kids have finished paying it off in taxes they can lobby for the tube extension in 2043.
Too crowded out to think about pedestrianisation of anything other than my life at the moment I’m afraid. BUT on the Silver Buckle — it’s in a terrible state if dis-repair. I reckon it needs minimum £100K spending on it before a penny goes on a decorative refurbishment just to get it into a lettable condition. Frank of Caravaggios agrees by the way . So S&N Pub Enterprises reckon £21K ingoings on a 25 year fully repairing insuring lease is possible. Anyone taking that on those terms would be down the pan within 18 months and then liable for the £100K that’s needed to bring the premises up to code.
Not a good deal if you ask me.
If one could buy the freehold on the other hand…
Lucas Gardens is saved. The Wilson Road residents association and Cllr Wingfield’s campaign has come good. The council offices by the park are to be taken by the Univ of the Arts who will not seek to annex any part of the park. We must welcome these intelligentsia in some fitting Camberwell way.
Had full English breakfast at Le Petit Parisien on Saturday.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/markdodds/4060421701/sizes/l/
Service willing, waitress pleasant and quick, struggled to keep up with number of customers, double egg and chips for the youngest boy arrived a GOOD ten minutes before three FEB’s made with good ingredients but sausages a little on the undecooked side. Waitress did say when Egg and chips arrived that the others would be in five minutes which seemed well informed but did force me to wonder ‘why make it and send it out if it’s a long time before the rest is ready?’. Condimentsleft some to be desired. Pepper damp and solid in cellar. Mustard had ketchup in it and around the ramekin which was grubby. Brown sauce about half a cm in the bottom of the bottle, most of which stayed in the bottle. Butter fridge hard, French par baked bread oddly stale tasting.
Not sure I’d rush back.
Had Sunday lunch at The Sun and Doves. Service very quick, food arrived soon all at the same time. You might think that’s only to be expected considering I own the place but you’d be more surprised how much it’s ‘family gets held back’ when we go there. Pork with all the trimmings more than I and the woman could eat. Staff said other customers manage to eat everything without too much trouble. Fennel gratin was flavoursome but really bland looking because undercooked. It needs to be caramelised. Too much carrot and swede mash. Pork was tender, thick slices, tasty with fairly decent crunchy crackling. The boys had a Cajun chicken burger and a hamburger — they say ouor burgers are the best they’ve eaten as do quite a few of our customers.
Special announcement. Robin — our new Head Chef started today. We’ve not had a ‘Head Chef’ for three years. The above issues will change.
Sunday Roast at The Sun and Doves:
http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2729/4070393890_3e643c111c_b.jpg
Dagmar — that’s great news about Lucas!
Great review on Le PP, Mark. Love the condiment detail. My mate went for Sunday Lunch at your place at the weekend, and he said it was really good.
LDA’s design for Burgess Park was declared the winning proposal by the council this morning.
http://tinyurl.com/ldadesign
If you’re interested, there is more info on LDA’s website:
http://www.lda-design.co.uk/news/burgess_park/
LDA wins it.
http://www.southwark.gov.uk/Public/NewsArticle.aspx?articleId=39811
I’m new to Camberwell & this blog, so hello all, nice to see such a strong indication of community spirit…
Great news about Lucas Gardens! Re: the trees getting the chop — I heard from one tree surgeon that they err heavily on the side of caution because they don’t want to get the blame for any headbanging branches etc. Any rot, wind-damage or even growing too close to a building is enough to get you the chop. There was some real heavy pruning going on with some of those trees, alot of it seemed unnecessary, I hope they recover.
I’m one of the folk who recently moved into South House (to keep squatters out until they figure out what they’re gonna do with it). Dagmar: that may’ve been m’lady & I you noticed looking for the funny mushrooms — none to be found unfortunately! Tho lots of lovely little ones all the same… I did some research online (can’t seem to find it now, was on the Colliers www) & the property brochure did show a red hatched area close to South House that they were offering as part of the deal.
I was under the impression that no sale has yet been confirmed, and apparently it’ll take 4 months for the paperwork to go thru anyway. But I hope the uni people buy it. It’s a really lovely old building — too lovely to be chopped up into flats, a bit spooky in places but I guess that’s to be expected from an old mental hospital.
Viva South House!
@ TheMule, I went to a party at East House on Halloween. It was great. I don’t know if you guys have the same, but they have amazing rooms.
Yes, the halloween party — they were kind enough to invite us over (in exchange for a few office chairs!) but we had other plans, so I haven’t seen their place yet… we do have some good spaces tho! If you’re ever passing by and you see us sat at the window feel free to come say hello — we’ve had a few drunks do so: a little more coherance is sometimes not such a bad thing.